• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

iBiology

Bringing the World's Best Biology to You

  • Start Here
    • Explore iBiology
    • All Playlists
    • All Speakers
    • All Talks
    • What’s new at iBiology?
  • Research Talks
    • Talks by Topic
      • Biochemistry
      • Bioengineering
      • Biophysics
      • Cell Biology
      • Development and Stem Cells
      • Ecology
      • Evolution
      • Genetics and Gene Regulation
      • Human Disease
      • Immunology
      • Microbiology
      • Neuroscience
      • Plant Biology
      • Techniques
      • Archive
    • Talks by Series
      • Bench to Bedside
      • Famous Discoveries
      • Great Unanswered Questions
      • Young Scientist Series
  • Stories
    • Background to Breakthrough
    • Interviews and Profiles
    • Science and Society
  • Courses
  • Careers
    • Professional Development Talks
    • Professional Development Courses
    • Career Exploration
    • NRMN Resources
    • Biomedical Workforce
  • Educator
  • About
    • Mission
    • iBiology Team
    • Board of Directors
    • Make a Donation
    • iBiology Funders and Partnerships
    • Contact Us
Home » Blog » Rethinking the Narrative of “Diversity in Science”

Rethinking the Narrative of “Diversity in Science”

May 9, 2018

Share

By Mónica I. Feliú-Mójer, Nina Griffin and Elliot Kirschner

Image credit: UCSF/Noah Berger.

Esteban Burchard is Latino. He grew up in poverty, raised by a single mother, and has faced discrimination all of his life. He is now a world renowned researcher and tenured professor at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF). Dr. Burchard’s “underdog story” reads like so many others told about scientists from underrepresented backgrounds. However, these narratives have become stale, are overused and devoid of important context and depth.

Of course, we must acknowledge there is a lot of truth in these underdog stories. We cannot deny that the barriers and oppression faced by people from marginalized groups make their path into science much harder. But, simply put, this overcoming-it-all narrative does a disservice to underrepresented scientists and, more generally, to the scientific endeavor. Viewing them through the underdog lens renders their experiences one dimensional. It negatively impacts the way they are perceived and diminishes the ability of people like them to see themselves as scientists. It also clouds the value of diversity in science and how it shapes scientific breakthroughs.

So when we went to tell Dr. Burchard’s story, we wanted to paint a much broader picture experimenting with a variety of storytelling strategies. How can we rethink the “diversity in science” narrative? Over the past year we at iBiology have been working on a collection of short films—called “Background to Breakthrough”—focused on how the identities, culture, and background of underrepresented scientists fuel their ingenuity and approaches to problem solving. Our inaugural effort profiles Dr. Burchard and his research on the genetic and environmental factors of asthma health disparities. In a trio of videos (ranging in length from roughly 4 to 7 minutes), we explore Dr. Burchard’s contributions to science, the role of race in medicine, and how his own ethnic and cultural background has contributed to his successful career.

The films focus sharply on Dr. Burchard, not only as a researcher, but a mentor, and an activist. Using storytelling strategies like speaking directly to viewers, using visual analogies, citing concrete examples, and reframing the underdog tale, the series shows how diversity enriches scientific research. How, to benefit people of all backgrounds, science truly needs to include everyone.

Speaking directly to viewers: When Burchard reveals that the asthma drug Serevent significantly increases the risk of death in African Americans, he breaks the fourth wall and directly asks the viewer: “If you were a parent, would you let your child use this?” By doing this, he invites the audience to tap into a universal human desire (wanting the best medical care for a loved one) and challenges them to reflect on the shortcomings of a healthcare system that has consistently discriminated against racial minorities.

Using visual analogies: Burchard describes race as a “shopping cart that contains lots of information that is relevant for clinical and biomedical research”. Through animation, we expand on this analogy to provide a unique framework to understand the relationship between race and biology. The animation also gives insight into how deeply Burchard thinks about the complexities of race and the creativity he employs to explain them in a compelling and accurate way.

Citing concrete examples: While there is a wealth of research demonstrating that diverse groups are better at problem solving than non-diverse groups, concrete examples of how this is true in science are rarely depicted. Burchard shares how his understanding of Latino culture helped him make sense of an important research finding that his white counterparts had been struggling to understand.

Reframing the “underdog” tale: Rather than defining Burchard as an underdog who rose to the top, we asked: how did he overcome the challenges he faced? We interviewed Burchard for hours and dug through hundreds of old photographs, to tell a more nuanced story and, for example, identify the multiple mentors that gave him the confidence, support, and guidance to succeed.

We see “Background to Breakthrough” as a series of science communication experiments. Will these stories change perceptions of who belongs to science, who science belongs to, and the paths to a scientific career? We are testing our approach by carefully evaluating the effectiveness of our storytelling strategies and how we distribute the films for maximum impact. We certainly hope that this project inspires viewers to rethink, in a more critical way, the narratives they hear about underrepresented scientists. Are these stories doing the scientists justice? What is missing? Who is missing? We hope that by challenging biases and conventional assumptions, “Background to Breakthrough” can help change the narratives of diversity in science.

This post originally appeared on Scientific American on May 7, 2018.

Any opinion, finding, conclusion, or recommendation expressed in this article and the “Background to Breakthrough” videos are solely those of the speaker and do not necessarily represent the views of iBiology, the National Science Foundation, the National Institutes of Health, or other iBiology funders.

The authors are the producers of “Background to Breakthrough”. They are part of iBiology, a non-profit organization that produces and distributes free online videos about research, the process of science, and professional development.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Help us keep bringing the world’s best biology to you!

Like our Website?

You'll love our newsletter...

  • Sign up for:
    • Exclusive iBiology content
    • 10 Must See Biology Videos
    • Talks by 20+ Nobel Winners
    • Our young Scientist Survival Toolkit
    • Talks by trailblazing Women in Biology
    • Updates on exciting iBiology projects in development
    Tyler Allen
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Privacy Policy

About Us

iBiology Teams
Make a donation
What’s new at iBiology?
Contact us
Join us
Mission
iBiology funders and partnerships
Report a problem
Login

Footer

Funders

NSF Logo
Lasker Logo
NIGMS Logo

Partners

Start Here

  • Talks for Everyone
  • Talks for Students
  • Talks for Research
  • Talks for Educators

Explore

  • Explore
  • All Playlists
  • All Speakers
  • All Talks

Talks By Topic

  • Biochemistry
  • Bioengineering
  • Biophysics
  • Cell Biology
  • Development and Stem Cells
  • Ecology
  • Genetics and Gene Regulation
  • Human Disease
  • Immunology
  • Microbiology
  • Neuroscience
  • Plant Biology
  • Techniques

Talks by Series

  • Bench to Bedside
  • Famous Discoveries
  • Great Questions
  • Share Your Research Series

Career

  • Professional Development
  • Career Exploration
  • NRMN Resources
  • Biomedical Workforce

Courses

  • Microscopy Series
  • Short Microscopy Series
  • Open edX Courses
  • Cell Biology Flipped Course
  • Engineering Life Flipped Course
  • Evolution Flipped Course

Educator

  • Educator Registration
  • Educator Resources
  • Log In

About Us

  • About Us
  • iBiology Team
  • Wonder Collaborative
  • Contact Us
  • Make a Donation
  • Mission
  • Privacy Policy

This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute of General Medical Sciences under Grant No. MCB-1052331. Any opinion, finding, conclusion, or recommendation expressed in these videos are solely those of the speaker and do not necessarily represent the views of iBiology, the National Science Foundation, the National Institutes of Health, or other iBiology funders.

© 2021 - 2006 iBiology · All content under CC BY-NC-ND 3.0 license · Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Usage Policy
 

Power by iBiology